Every rule below comes from Chicago's own published list of changes for the 18th edition and from the Chicago editors' answers on their official Q&A and blog. Paragraph numbers (such as 8.160) refer to the 18th edition, so you can look each one up.

1. Prepositions of five or more letters are now capitalized (8.160)

This is the change most writers will notice. Under the 17th edition, Chicago lowercased prepositions in a title no matter how long they were, a rule it had spelled out since its 12th edition in 1969. The 18th edition capitalizes a preposition once it reaches five letters. Chicago's own pair of examples shows the line: A Room with a View (four letters, lowercase) but Much Ado About Nothing (five letters, capitalized).

InputChicago 17Chicago 18
much ado about nothingMuch Ado about NothingMuch Ado About Nothing
the road through the mountainsThe Road through the MountainsThe Road Through the Mountains
life without limitsLife without LimitsLife Without Limits
the day after tomorrowThe Day after TomorrowThe Day After Tomorrow
the gospel according to matthewThe Gospel according to MatthewThe Gospel According to Matthew
a room with a viewA Room with a ViewA Room with a View
letters from homeLetters from HomeLetters from Home

Phrasal prepositions changed too. Chicago's editors note that the old rule led them to write The Gospel according to Matthew; they now style it The Gospel According to Matthew.

Short prepositions are unchanged. With, from, into, over, upon, like and every shorter preposition stay lowercase in the middle of a title, and Chicago keeps as lowercase whatever job it is doing in the sentence.

2. "Headline style" is now called "title case" (8.159, 8.160)

Chicago dropped its old names. What earlier editions called headline style is now title case, and sentence style is now sentence case. The rules themselves are what the rest of this article describes; only the names changed, so style sheets and editorial notes written for the 17th edition may need new wording.

3. Words after a prefix follow the normal rule (8.162)

In a hyphenated term that starts with a prefix, such as anti-, pre- or non-, the part after the hyphen is now capitalized by the general title-case rule. Chicago's example is Anti-Intellectual Pursuits; earlier editions kept the second part lowercase (Anti-intellectual Pursuits). See our guide to hyphenated words in title case for how other guides handle this.

4. A full sentence after a colon now starts with a capital (6.67)

This one is about running text rather than titles. When a colon introduces a grammatically complete sentence, the 18th edition now capitalizes its first word: The answer was simple: We would start again. Titles were already covered by a separate rule, since the first word of a subtitle after a colon is capitalized.

5. An initial "The" in newspaper and magazine names (8.172)

When a periodical's official name starts with The, Chicago now capitalizes and italicizes it in running text along with the rest of the name: The New York Times. Earlier editions treated the article as part of the surrounding sentence (the New York Times). Source citations can still leave the article out.

The tricky word: "than"

Than can be a conjunction or a preposition, and Chicago treats the two differently. When a noun follows it as its object, it is a preposition and can stay lowercase: There Is More than One Path to a Successful Meal. When a clause follows, it is a conjunction and gets a capital: A Successful Meal Requires More Than I Bargained For. The Chicago editors add that it may be simpler to capitalize than in both cases. Our converter takes that simpler route and always capitalizes it under Chicago.

Other capitalization changes worth knowing

The 18th edition also changed a number of capitalization rules outside titles. A few that come up often:

  • A title before a name stays capitalized even with an adjective in front of it: former President Carter (8.22).
  • Midwestern and Midwesterner are now capitalized (8.48).
  • Adjectives taken from proper nouns follow the first-listed entry in Merriam-Webster, even when the sense isn't literal: Swiss cheese (8.62).
  • Time zone names are capitalized (Central Daylight Time), but not the generic form (Central time) (8.91).
  • Big Bang is capitalized when it refers to the origin of the universe (8.149).

What this means for your titles

If you formatted titles under the 17th edition, the only titles that need to change are ones with a preposition of five or more letters in the middle (about, after, under, through, without, between and so on), plus any hyphenated term that starts with a prefix. Everything else comes out the same.

The change also brings Chicago closer to AP and APA, which capitalize prepositions from four letters. The styles now disagree only about four-letter prepositions such as with and from; see AP vs Chicago for the full comparison.

The Chicago option in our title case converter follows the 18th edition, and the Chicago title case page lists the full rule set. To check one word, such as about or than, use capitalization by word.

Sources