Is “By” capitalized in a title?
Not in the middle of a title. All eight major style guides keep “by” lowercase there. It is capitalized only as the first word, the last word (except in Bluebook), or the first word after a colon.
The rule in each style guide
When “by” sits in the middle of a title (not first, not last, not right after a colon):
| Guide | Mid-title | Why | Source |
|---|---|---|---|
| AP Stylebook | by | Lowercase: 2-letter preposition | Checked against the guide |
| Chicago Manual of Style | by | Lowercase: 2-letter preposition | Checked against the guide |
| APA Style | by | Lowercase: 2-letter preposition | Checked against the guide |
| MLA Handbook | by | Lowercase: 2-letter preposition | Checked against the guide |
| New York Times | by | Lowercase: 2-letter preposition | Secondary sources |
| Wikipedia Manual of Style | by | Lowercase: 2-letter preposition | Checked against the guide |
| The Bluebook | by | Lowercase: 2-letter preposition | Rule text as quoted |
| AMA Manual of Style | by | Lowercase: 2-letter preposition | Checked against the guide |
Positions that change the answer
- First word: always capitalized, in every guide (“By …”).
- Last word: capitalized in seven guides. Bluebook has no last-word exception, so it stays “by” there.
- After a colon: the first word after a colon is capitalized in every guide.
- Anywhere else: follow the table above.
What kind of word “by” is
“By” is a preposition. Title-case rules turn on word class and length, so that is what each guide above is reacting to.
Examples
| Guide | stand by me | death by chocolate |
|---|---|---|
| AP Stylebook | Stand by Me | Death by Chocolate |
| Chicago Manual of Style | Stand by Me | Death by Chocolate |
| APA Style | Stand by Me | Death by Chocolate |
| MLA Handbook | Stand by Me | Death by Chocolate |
| New York Times | Stand by Me | Death by Chocolate |
| Wikipedia Manual of Style | Stand by Me | Death by Chocolate |
| The Bluebook | Stand by Me | Death by Chocolate |
| AMA Manual of Style | Stand by Me | Death by Chocolate |