Most of the eight style guides agree on most words. All of them lowercase a, an, the, and, but, or, and short prepositions such as of, in and on in the middle of a title. The differences come down to a handful of words, and they're easiest to see by running the same title through every guide.

One title, eight guides

Each table shows a title as each guide capitalizes it. Highlighted words are the ones that guide treats differently from the majority.

Input: notes from the field

GuideResult
APNotes From the Field
ChicagoNotes from the Field
APANotes From the Field
MLANotes from the Field
New York TimesNotes From the Field
WikipediaNotes from the Field
BluebookNotes from the Field
AMANotes From the Field

Input: a walk through the woods with friends

GuideResult
APA Walk Through the Woods With Friends
ChicagoA Walk Through the Woods with Friends
APAA Walk Through the Woods With Friends
MLAA Walk through the Woods with Friends
New York TimesA Walk Through the Woods With Friends
WikipediaA Walk Through the Woods with Friends
BluebookA Walk Through the Woods with Friends
AMAA Walk Through the Woods With Friends

Input: what to do if it rains

GuideResult
APWhat to Do if It Rains
ChicagoWhat to Do If It Rains
APAWhat to Do if It Rains
MLAWhat to Do If It Rains
New York TimesWhat to Do if It Rains
WikipediaWhat to Do If It Rains
BluebookWhat to Do if It Rains
AMAWhat to Do If It Rains

Input: everything you need to know about taxes

GuideResult
APEverything You Need to Know About Taxes
ChicagoEverything You Need to Know About Taxes
APAEverything You Need to Know About Taxes
MLAEverything You Need to Know about Taxes
New York TimesEverything You Need to Know About Taxes
WikipediaEverything You Need to Know About Taxes
BluebookEverything You Need to Know About Taxes
AMAEverything You Need to Know About Taxes

Input: a place to come back to

GuideResult
APA Place to Come Back To
ChicagoA Place to Come Back To
APAA Place to Come Back To
MLAA Place to Come Back To
New York TimesA Place to Come Back To
WikipediaA Place to Come Back To
BluebookA Place to Come Back to
AMAA Place to Come Back To

The words that split the guides

These are the words where the guides disagree, as each guide treats them in the middle of a title. Articles, coordinating conjunctions, prepositions of three letters or fewer, and nouns, verbs, adjectives, adverbs and pronouns are treated the same way by all eight.

WordAPChicagoAPAMLANYTWikipediaBluebookAMA
fromCaplowerCaplowerCaplowerlowerCap
withCaplowerCaplowerCaplowerlowerCap
likeCaplowerCaplowerCaplowerlowerCap
aboutCapCapCaplowerCapCapCapCap
throughCapCapCaplowerCapCapCapCap
thanCapCapCapCapCapCaplowerCap
iflowerCaplowerCaplowerCaplowerCap
whenCapCapCapCapCapCaplowerCap
  • Prepositions of four letters (from, with, like, into, over): capitalized by AP, APA, the New York Times and AMA; lowercase in Chicago, Wikipedia, Bluebook and MLA.
  • Longer prepositions (about, through, between): capitalized by every guide except MLA, which lowercases prepositions of any length.
  • Short subordinating conjunctions (if): capitalized by Chicago, MLA, Wikipedia and AMA; lowercase in AP, APA, the New York Times and Bluebook, which lowercase conjunctions by length.
  • The last word: every guide capitalizes it except Bluebook, so A Place to Come Back to keeps a lowercase to only in Bluebook.

Which guide should you use?

  • AP: news writing, press releases and many blogs.
  • Chicago: book publishing and much academic and general nonfiction writing.
  • APA: psychology, education and the social sciences.
  • MLA: literature, languages and the humanities.
  • New York Times: headlines in the Times house style.
  • Wikipedia: titles of works cited in Wikipedia articles.
  • Bluebook: legal citations in the United States.
  • AMA: medicine and health sciences.

If you don't have to follow a particular guide, pick one and use it consistently. To check a title of your own against all eight at once, use the title checker.

Questions

What's the difference between AP and Chicago title case?
Mainly four-letter prepositions. AP capitalizes prepositions of four or more letters, so With and From are capitalized; Chicago capitalizes them only from five letters, so with and from stay lowercase.

Which style guide lowercases the most words?
MLA. It lowercases prepositions of any length, so about, through and between stay lowercase in an MLA title.

Do all style guides capitalize the last word of a title?
All the guides here do except Bluebook, which has no special rule for the last word.